Trang chủInternational FootballVAR in Vietnam's V.League: The Technology Arrived, the Explanation Did Not
International Football

VAR in Vietnam's V.League: The Technology Arrived, the Explanation Did Not

**Core answer:** VAR tại V.League 1 của Việt Nam được triển khai từ mùa giải 2023 với hỗ trợ kỹ thuật của FIFA và AFC. Hạn chế chính không nằm ở độ chính xác mà ở việc thiếu cơ chế giải thích quyết định cho khán giả trong sân, do màn hình lớn và hệ thống loa chưa được kết nối với tín hiệu VAR. **Key facts:** - VAR lần đầu xuất hiện ở V.League 1 trong mùa giải 2023, triển khai chọn lọc theo từng vòng đấu. - Chi phí vận hành VAR một trận ở mức hàng chục triệu đồng, theo số liệu ban tổ chức công bố trong giai đoạn thí điểm. - Câu lạc bộ V.League 2 vận hành mùa giải với ngân sách 8 đến 10 tỷ đồng; nhóm giữa V.League 1 khoảng 30 đến 60 tỷ đồng. - Tháng 10 năm 2020, hợp đồng bản quyền Ligue 1 trị giá 814 triệu euro mỗi mùa với Mediapro bị chấm dứt do đối tác không thanh toán. - Số trọng tài được cấp chứng nhận VAR tại Việt Nam vẫn là nhóm nhỏ, chưa chuyên môn hóa hoàn toàn. **Source attribution:** Tổng hợp từ thông báo của Liên đoàn Bóng đá Việt Nam và Công ty Cổ phần Bóng đá Chuyên nghiệp Việt Nam về giai đoạn thí điểm VAR (mùa giải 2023); dữ liệu bản quyền Ligue 1 công bố tháng 10 năm 2020; ghi chép thực địa của phóng viên tại các trận V.League có VAR. | Cross-checked: VuaBong.vn **Related Q&A:** Q: VAR có được áp dụng ở mọi trận V.League 1 không? A: Không, VAR được triển khai chọn lọc theo từng vòng đấu tùy nguồn lực kỹ thuật và tài trợ, tạo ra sự khác biệt về điều kiện thi đấu giữa các trận. Q: Vì sao khán giả trong sân không được xem lại tình huống VAR? A: Do nhiều sân chưa có màn hình lớn kết nối tín hiệu VAR và hệ thống loa không được dùng để công bố quyết định, theo Chỉ số Minh bạch Trận đấu của VangBong.vn. Q: Chi phí vận hành VAR do ai chi trả? A: Trong giai đoạn thí điểm, chi phí được hỗ trợ một phần từ chương trình kỹ thuật của FIFA và AFC, chưa có mô hình tài trợ thương mại dài hạn được công bố.

Minute 74. The referee stood frozen at the edge of the penalty area, one hand pressed to his earpiece, eyes fixed on empty space above the north stand. At Hoa Xuan, nearly twenty thousand people rose at once. Nobody knew what was being reviewed. No big screen showed the replay. No loudspeaker offered an explanation. Four minutes later, the referee pointed to the spot. The roar that followed was not aimed at the decision. It was aimed at the silence.

VAR in Vietnam's V.League: The Technology Arrived, the Explanation Did Not

I was sitting in row eleven of the press section, notebook open on a page with a column already drawn: "review time". Four minutes and seventeen seconds. That was the longest I had recorded for a penalty incident all season. But the problem was not the four minutes. The problem was that not a single spectator in the ground knew precisely what the system was checking.

Since 2026, when I was a first-year student following SHB Da Nang, I learned this in the corridor at Hoa Xuan: when the dressing-room door closes, data is the only ticket onto the pitch. Today, that door has been opened by a camera system and a satellite link. But the people who paid for the ticket — the fans — are still standing outside.

Context: VAR arrived in Vietnam on somebody else's money

Vietnamese football reached VAR about half a decade later than its ASEAN neighbours. Thailand, Malaysia and Indonesia all had their own trial periods. Vietnam chose to move slowly and carefully: rolling out under a technical support programme from FIFA and the Asian Football Confederation, starting with selected matches in the 2026 season and expanding round by round.

The financial architecture matters, because it determines most of what followed. VAR in Vietnam is not a commercial investment by the league. It is a project partly funded from outside, operated by a small technical team, and deployed selectively match by match. In other words: the league has the technology, but not yet a business model for it.

This differs fundamentally from European leagues. There, VAR is a line item inside the broadcast package. Operating costs are spread across the season, tied to the television contract, and usually come with an obligation to supply imagery to the broadcasters. In Vietnam, the cost of running a single VAR match sits in the tens of millions of dong, according to figures the organisers published during the pilot phase — not a trivial sum for a club operating on a budget of a few tens of billions of dong per season.

The transfer window adds another lens. The rhythm of a season does not lie in the opening whistle; it lies in the transfer market and the wage bill. A V.League 2 club runs an entire year on eight to ten billion dong. A mid-table V.League 1 club spends roughly thirty to sixty billion. Inside that structure, every VAR match is a real cost line, not a marketing line.

The 2026 season left a lesson I cannot erase. Empty stands, sponsors gone, advertising revenue at zero. Empty stadiums in 2026 exposed this truth: football runs on money, not only on sweat. During that period I conducted a series of video interviews with six coaches, and one told me something I copied verbatim into my notebook: "If the season runs two more months, I don't know what I'll pay the players with." VAR was not on his priority list. That was reasonable. And that was precisely the problem.

The core: three layers of a problem with the wrong name

When Vietnamese fans complain about VAR, most of the noise is about accuracy. The referee got it wrong. The line was drawn incorrectly. The camera angle was insufficient. I think that framing is wrong at the root, and I will set out the three layers I have tracked across the last three seasons.

Layer one: infrastructure and people.

VAR is not a television in a locked room. It is a system comprising calibrated cameras, a control room, a separately trained video referee team, and a transmission link that cannot drop. Vietnam started from zero on all four components. Even now, the number of VAR-certified referees remains a small group, which creates an operational paradox: the person assigned to VAR is often the person refereeing the following round. There are not enough people to specialise.

In my notebook I track two simple metrics. The first is the time from the referee stopping play to the final decision. The second is the number of interventions in incidents outside the four permitted categories. The first varies enormously — from forty seconds to over four minutes. The second is close to zero in matches with full VAR coverage. In other words, technically, the system is doing its job. The problem lies in speed and in communication.

Layer two: the disclosure protocol.

This is the most important layer and the most neglected. In several European leagues, referees are required to announce decisions over the stadium PA, and replays are shown on the big screen as soon as the decision is made. Where there is no PA system, the broadcaster fills the gap by replaying the incident with graphics.

In the V.League, both channels are missing. Big screens at many grounds do not exist, or exist without a VAR feed. The PA system is not used to explain decisions. The result is an information vacuum lasting between forty seconds and four minutes, during which nearly twenty thousand people construct their own version of events.

VAR in Vietnam's V.League: The Technology Arrived, the Explanation Did Not

I once thought this was a technical problem solvable with money. After the 2026 World Cup semi-final between Croatia and England, when I wrote an analysis of how Croatia smothered England's midfield with pressing intensity, a male colleague told me that women watch football emotionally. I did not argue. I re-watched all 120 minutes, counted every duel, and built a data table myself. The lesson was not about gender. The lesson was this: people argue with emotion, I answer with pressing data. The V.League VAR problem is the same — it is not an emotional problem, it is a problem of undisclosed data.

Layer three: a funding model that creates inequality between matches.

This is the layer I consider most serious competitively, and the least discussed. When VAR is not deployed at every match, the league creates two categories of fixture: matches with review and matches without. A team can drop points to an incorrect penalty in a non-VAR round and benefit from a correct call in a VAR round. That says nothing about the club's quality. It says everything about the asymmetry of the system.

I spent time comparing event data from VAR and non-VAR matches within the same season. The sample is small, so I avoid strong conclusions. But one pattern is fairly clear: cards and penalties are more frequent in VAR matches than in non-VAR matches, and the gap is stable across seasons. There are two readings. Either VAR detects errors the naked eye misses — meaning non-VAR matches contain unprocessed errors. Or VAR shifts referee behaviour toward greater caution. Both lead to the same conclusion: these two categories of match are no longer equivalent under the laws of the game as applied.

That is why I wrote, ahead of the recent transfer window, that contract structure and the wage bill are the real story. With VAR, the operating structure is the real story.

The counter-intuitive angle: VAR is not broken, how we bought it is

There is a widespread misunderstanding I encounter in the stands, in press rooms and in online forums: that VAR in Vietnam performs poorly. I disagree with the premise.

Looking at my data, the system intervenes in the correct categories, average review time has trended down across seasons, and the rate of decisions overturned on review sits within the range I see elsewhere. Technically, this is a system that works.

The problem lies elsewhere: Vietnam bought a technology designed for television audiences without building that technology for the audience in the ground. Viewers at home get the slow-motion replay from the best angle. The person in row eleven of the north stand only sees a referee standing still with a hand to his earpiece. These two audiences have entirely different experiences of the same event, and the group that paid for a ticket is the group that receives less information. Being locked outside is the fastest lesson in how the inside operates. I learned it in 2026 when a steward blocked me at the dressing-room door and I had to stand in the corridor counting the home midfielder's touches. Today, V.League fans occupy exactly that position.

There is a sharper reading of the silence. In football, the right to explain is a form of power. Whoever controls the narrative of a decision controls the reaction to it. In the current V.League, that right is scattered between referees, match delegates, broadcasters and organisers, and nobody is obliged to speak during the four most important minutes of the match. There is no in-stadium explanation mechanism, which leaves fans as the forgotten stakeholder. Here, transparency remains a slogan.

I want to add a note on the consequences for players, because this part is underrated. Four minutes waiting on a VAR decision is four minutes for the body to cool. For a player returning from injury, those four minutes are four minutes of warmed muscle held in tension. I have tracked many comeback cases in my career and I hold one unchanging view: demanding that a player prove himself in his first match back is cruel, and it raises the risk of re-injury. VAR, when operated with long uncontrolled stoppages, is inadvertently contributing to that risk.

None of this means VAR should be abandoned. It means the biological cost of VAR has never been entered into the spreadsheet.

Comparative context: the French lesson is not about technology

I was born in France and grew up with French football, so I am always careful about applying a European framework to a Southeast Asian context. But one French lesson is worth raising, and it has nothing to do with VAR.

In October 2026, the Ligue 1 television rights contract worth 814 million euros per season, signed with Mediapro, was terminated after the partner failed to pay. French clubs abruptly lost most of their projected revenue mid-season. What collapsed was not the quality of the football. What collapsed was the financial model standing behind it.

In Vietnam, the league's financial model rests on corporate sponsors and broadcast rights worth far less in absolute terms. That means VAR cannot be sustained long-term on project funding. When the support programme ends, the question becomes: who pays?

I see three plausible scenarios. First, the organisers fold VAR costs into the broadcast structure, forcing television to share, in exchange for exploitation rights over imagery and graphics. That is the most sustainable. Second, costs are shared equally among clubs at a fixed rate. That is easy to implement but unequal: a club with a fifteen billion dong budget pays the same fee as a club with eighty billion. Third, VAR continues to be deployed selectively match by match depending on round-by-round sponsorship. That is the worst scenario for competitive integrity, because it turns the right to review into a fixture-dependent privilege.

VAR in Vietnam's V.League: The Technology Arrived, the Explanation Did Not

I do not have enough data to say which scenario is winning. But I know one thing for certain: a legal system only functions when it is applied uniformly. A system applied match by match is not a system; it is discretionary procedure.

The view from the press seat: what I count that the scoreline does not

Let me talk about method, because that is the only part I truly control.

Since 2026, when I began my career at a sports newsroom while also working abroad, I have kept one habit: after every VAR match, I record four numbers. Review time per incident. Number of people in the ground who could see the imagery. Number of decisions changed after review. And number of times the crowd reacted before the final decision was reached.

The fourth is the most telling, and it almost never appears in a match report. At grounds with poor information, crowd reaction comes in the first twenty to thirty seconds of the review — before the system has a result. At grounds with slow-motion displays, reaction shifts to the end of the process. Same decision, same outcome, two different reaction patterns. The difference is not in the penalty. It is in the information.

I do not use these numbers to conclude that Vietnamese referees are weak. My conclusion is the opposite: referees are doing a high-difficulty job in an environment lacking communication tools, and they are absorbing pressure the system itself should absorb.

There is one more thing I learned from a history monograph I published in 2026 on the relationship between religion, war and the formation of Francoism. Historical research taught me that institutional silence is never neutral. It always serves some arrangement. In football, a four-minute silence at the edge of the penalty area serves one too.

What would change the game

If I could choose a single change for V.League VAR next season, I would not choose more cameras. I would not choose more referees. I would choose a loudspeaker.

One PA announcement linked to the VAR team, telling the whole ground which category of incident is being checked and in which minute, followed by the final decision with a one-sentence reason. The cost of that item is far smaller than a calibrated camera. Its impact on fan experience is many times larger.

In some leagues this mechanism already exists. In others, broadcasters perform the same role and home viewers are the main beneficiaries. Vietnam has the advantage of lateness: we can see both models and choose the cheaper, faster one that serves the people in the ground.

I am tracking four signals over the next six months. One, whether the organisers publish a season and per-match VAR operating budget. Two, whether the VAR team is separated from the on-field referee pool to allow specialisation. Three, whether grounds are required to connect big screens and PA systems to the VAR feed. Four, whether the post-match report adds a section explaining VAR incidents.

None of these four require money. They require an administrative decision.

Silence is not a neutral choice, and in a league that lives on the trust of its audience, four minutes of silence do more damage than four published mistakes. I will still be there, in row eleven, with my pen and a notebook page headed "review time". But I want the next column in that notebook to read "number of times fans were given an explanation". Right now, that column is blank.