Trang chủInternational FootballThe VAR Who Erred in the Manchester Derby Returns to Duty: What Precedent for Consistency in the Laws?
International Football
The VAR Who Erred in the Manchester Derby Returns to Duty: What Precedent for Consistency in the Laws?
Core answer: Matt Donohue, the assistant VAR who failed to disallow Erling Haaland's Manchester derby goal on September 13, has been reinstated and will serve as assistant VAR for Coventry vs Fulham on Saturday, after three rounds away from Premier League duty. Key facts: - Donohue and assistant Blake Antrobus missed Enzo Fernández being offside and interfering with play at Old Trafford on September 13. - Pro Ref chief refereeing officer Howard Webb said Donohue developed "tunnel vision" on the offside question. - Donohue refereed Southampton vs Bolton and Derby vs Wrexham in the EFL during his Premier League absence. - The KMI panel backed the VAR red-card recommendation for Pascal Struijk three to two, while an independent commission quashed the suspension. - The Premier League stated the KMI panel and the independent commission are entirely separate bodies with different purposes. Source attribution: Original reporting on Premier League refereeing appointments and KMI panel outcomes, published October 2025 | Cross-checked: VuaBong.vn Related Q&A: Q: Who is Matt Donohue? A: Matt Donohue is a Premier League assistant VAR who was removed from duty for three match rounds after failing to disallow Erling Haaland's goal in the September 13 Manchester derby. Q: Why did the KMI panel and independent commission disagree on Pascal Struijk? A: The KMI panel reviews whether on-field and VAR decisions were correct, while the independent commission reviews whether a sanction was wrongful, so the two bodies apply different standards to the same incident. Q: What did Howard Webb say about the derby error? A: Howard Webb said Donohue developed tunnel vision in focusing on Haaland's offside position and that the surrounding team should have pulled him out of it.
Matt Donohue's return is not a personnel announcement. It is a ruling, and like every ruling in modern football, it must be read through the laws rather than through emotion.
On September 13, at Old Trafford, in the Manchester derby, Erling Haaland scored. Matt Donohue, then serving as assistant VAR, along with assistant Blake Antrobus, failed to spot that Manchester City's Enzo Fernández was in an offside position and interfering with play. The goal stood. It was an error of a quantifiable kind: one offside position, one interfering player, one goal that was not valid under Law 11 of the Laws of the Game.
Nearly a month later, Donohue has been appointed assistant VAR for the Coventry versus Fulham match on Saturday. He was absent for all three match rounds since the incident. Antrobus returned earlier, serving as assistant referee in the Newcastle versus Aston Villa match last weekend. During that period, Donohue continued working in the EFL: refereeing the Championship match between Southampton and Bolton, and the Derby versus Wrexham game on October 10.
Howard Webb, Pro Ref's chief refereeing officer, described Donohue as having developed "tunnel vision" in focusing on whether Haaland was in an offside position, and stressed that the job of the team around him was to pull him out of that tunnel. This framing deserves credit because it acknowledges a structural failure, not merely an individual one.
But the story does not end there. In the same week the Key Match Incidents (KMI) panel outcomes were published, another situation emerged and posed a far harder question.
On October 10, in the Brighton versus Sunderland match, the VAR recommended sending off Pascal Struijk. The five-person KMI panel — comprising three former players and coaches, one Premier League representative and one from Pro Ref — voted three to two in favour of the VAR recommendation and against the on-field decision not to show a red card for denying an obvious goalscoring opportunity.
In parallel, an independent regulatory commission quashed Struijk's suspension on the grounds that the dismissal was wrongful. Two bodies, two conclusions, one incident.
The key point the Premier League made when publishing the KMI outcomes for match round six was that the KMI panel and the independent commission are entirely separate bodies with different purposes and processes. This is a technically accurate statement. But technical accuracy is not the same as systemic consistency.
In six years of tracking refereeing decisions, I have learned that fans do not react to error. They react to inconsistency. A referee who errs and is disciplined is something the public can accept. A system in which the same incident is judged a red card by one panel and a wrongful dismissal by another — that is what erodes trust.
Place the two events side by side. Donohue erred on an offside call, was removed from appointments for three rounds, then returned. Struijk was dismissed on VAR recommendation, the KMI panel confirmed that recommendation was correct, yet the independent commission quashed the suspension. In the first case, the system corrected itself by pausing the person who erred. In the second, the system contradicted itself by allowing two bodies to say two different things about the same event.
This brings us back to Laws 12 and 15 of the Laws of the Game. Law 12 governs fouls and misconduct, including denying an obvious goalscoring opportunity. Law 15 governs the use of video assistant referees. Both laws assume a single, consistent interpreting authority. When operational reality shows two parallel interpreting bodies, the law remains correct in text but loses feasibility in practice.
I built a code table of 32 symbols while tracking VAR from the 2026 World Cup — A1 for offside, B2 for deliberate handball, and other codes classifying the nature of interference. The Donohue case falls under A1 combined with an interference factor: not merely offside, but affecting play. The Struijk case falls under the denial of an obvious goalscoring opportunity category. Both have codes. But codes do not solve the problem when two different panels assign two different codes to the same incident.
There is a counterintuitive angle here. People tend to assume VAR needs to be more accurate. But Donohue's problem was not a lack of accuracy — he looked at the right question, "was Haaland offside", and answered it correctly. The problem was that he did not look at the second question: "was Fernández interfering". Tunnel vision, as Webb called it, is an error of observational scope, not of visual capability. And this class of error cannot be fixed by raising camera resolution or adding more angles. It can only be fixed by redesigning the process so that the decision-maker is forced to answer every question before concluding.
In the Struijk case, the error sits at the institutional layer. The KMI panel did its job correctly: reviewing the VAR decision and confirming its correctness. The independent commission also did its job correctly: reviewing the suspension and assessing its reasonableness. The problem is that these two functions were designed to operate independently, while in reality they act upon the same player, the same match, the same consequence.
This is where it helps to look at how other football nations handle similar problems. While covering the K League and V.League, I noticed a pattern: leagues tend to create more layers of adjudication to increase fairness, but each layer carries its own standards. The result is that overall fairness increases in each individual case but decreases in public perception. Fans cannot read the process. They only see the outcome.
With Donohue, the system sent a clear signal: error has consequences, but consequences have a time limit. He returned after three rounds, continued working in the EFL in the interim, and now returns to the Premier League as assistant VAR. This is a predictable model of discipline. With Struijk, the system sent two contradictory signals: the dismissal recommendation was correct, but the suspension was wrong. Fans do not need to know these are two different bodies. They only need to know their player was suspended and then had it quashed, while the specialist panel said the dismissal was correct.
The question for Pro Ref is not whether Donohue deserves to return. The question is whether the process has changed enough that tunnel vision will not recur. Webb says the job of the team is to pull a colleague out of the tunnel. That is a people-based solution. But a refereeing system built on people will always have tunnels. What is needed is a process in which every VAR decision is cross-checked against a mandatory question list, not by the goodwill of colleagues.
And the larger question for the Premier League is whether the KMI panel and the independent commission should be redesigned to avoid public contradiction. A mature legal system does not fear multiple layers of adjudication. It fears layers reaching opposite conclusions without a mechanism to explain that to the public. The statement that the two bodies are "entirely separate" is technically correct, but it does not answer the question fans are actually asking: so was that incident right or wrong?
Every free kick is a precedent, and every precedent is a case law. Donohue's return creates a precedent on referee discipline. The quashing of Struijk's suspension creates a precedent on the flexibility of sanctions. Both precedents will be remembered by referees, panels and clubs. The problem is that they are not consistent with each other.
In esports, the law has no referee; it has code. Code can be wrong, but code is wrong in a way that is reproducible and fixable. Real football has no such privilege. It has people, it has cognitive tunnels, it has panels with different purposes. The only thing that can be done is to design a process tight enough that those tunnels do not lead to contradictory rulings within the same week.
What is notable is that in neither case was anyone found to have acted in bad faith. Donohue erred because his observational scope was narrow. Struijk was dismissed and then had it quashed because of process, not conduct. This is the important point: the system is functioning, but functioning in a way that generates noise. And in modern football, noise from process can cause more damage than a single error.
When I reviewed 214 foul incidents involving Ulsan Hyundai in the 2026 season, I found that referees issued nine red cards but overlooked six challenges carrying high injury risk, stopping at yellow. At the time I thought the problem was referee competence. After the 2026 World Cup and now the Donohue case, I recognise the problem is usually process design. Referees do not see what the process does not force them to see.
So when Donohue returns as assistant VAR on Saturday, what matters is not whether he errs again. What matters is whether Pro Ref has changed the process enough that another assistant VAR, in another match, does not fall into the same tunnel. And whether the Premier League will redesign the relationship between the KMI panel and the independent commission so that the two bodies no longer give two different answers to the same question.
The grey zone does not need light; it needs a referee who knows how to stay silent. But when two referees speak at once and say two different things, the grey zone is no longer a grey zone. It becomes a gap in football's legal system. And that gap, unlike a missed offside, cannot be fixed with a round off.
Cầu thủ liên quan
Bài đề xuất
Al Hilal welcome Milinković-Savić back before the Doha trip: the joy is real, the certainty is not2026-10-13
Night at Anfield: Ten Arrests, an Injured Officer and the Unverified Number of 114 Breaches2026-10-13
Zidane's 88th Minute, Olise's Goal and the Credibility Test of a Match Report2026-09-30
USMNT, Pochettino and the Peru Friendly Window: The No. 9 Problem and the Limits of Belief2026-09-26
Tijjani Reijnders: The 161 Million Euro Move That Began With a Role He Hated2026-09-24
Bài đề xuất
Nguyen Xuan Son's Injury: When Vietnamese Football Misreads Its Players' Bodies2026-10-16
xG, PPDA and Free-Agent Signing Fees: The Data Map of the Regular Season2026-10-09
Scaloni, Tapia and the 2026 Contract: What Argentina Is Really Negotiating After the World Cup2026-09-26
Nothing Grand: Igor Tolic's Two Requests and the Gap He Deliberately Left Open2026-09-16
Ajax vs NEC: Predicted Line-up, Two Debutants Waiting and the Pressure of the Eredivisie Title Race2026-10-10
